News

Vinyl or laminate flooring: a retailer’s honest comparison

Plancher Vinyle
Plancher Vinyle
Vinyl
Plancher Laminé
Laminate

You’re in the store, standing in front of two boxes of flooring. Same look, same promises: waterproof, easy to install. Yet one costs twice as much as the other, and neither tells you what will happen once the floor is down.

Vinyl or laminate flooring: which one should you choose? We spoke with Filippo Tomasino, President and CEO of Planchers Payless, who has more than 40 years of experience in renovation. The company, a retailer in the Greater Montreal area, has been selling flooring for 15 years.

Key takeaways

  • About 80% of Planchers Payless customers ask for vinyl, convinced it’s 100% waterproof.
  • Vinyl flooring resists water from mopping, but not a flood.
  • At 5 to 7 mm, it breaks if the subfloor isn’t perfectly level; at 8 to 10 mm, the locking system holds.
  • Laminate 10 to 12 mm thick resists scratches much better.
  • At equal quality, vinyl and laminate both cost $2 to $3 per square foot.

Vinyl or laminate flooring: which to choose for each room?

Vinyl suits rooms exposed to water (basement, laundry room, entryway, kitchen), while 10 to 12 mm laminate, warmer and more scratch-resistant, suits the rest of the house.

In Quebec, sales of vinyl flooring have far outpaced those of laminate flooring over the past five years. The many water damage incidents that homes here go through have a lot to do with it. On price, nothing separates them: $2 to $3 per square foot at equal quality.

In the basement, laundry room and entryway

Vinyl is the way to go in rooms exposed to water: basement, laundry room, entryway where you come in with wet boots. It resists water from mopping indefinitely.

In the kitchen

A kitchen gets washed often, sometimes with lots of water. Here too, vinyl holds up better than laminate.

On the ground floor and upstairs

For the rest of the house, laminate is making a comeback. Thicker and warmer underfoot, it above all has a far more resistant aluminum oxide surface.

“We did the test with a key. On vinyl, the key bites into the surface. On laminate, there's no way to get through.”

Filippo Tomasino
President and CEO of Planchers Payless

Good to know: have a dog? Choose laminate, never vinyl.

Is vinyl flooring really waterproof?

Vinyl flooring resists water from mopping indefinitely, but not a flood: water gets underneath, and removing the floor breaks the locking system in about 75% of cases.

About 80% of customers who walk into Planchers Payless ask for vinyl, convinced by the internet that it’s 100% waterproof. That’s true, but only up to a point.

Like laminate, vinyl is most often installed as a floating floor. During a flood, water flows all around the planks, and even underneath:

  • Dirty water: the floor is contaminated and must be torn out.
  • Clean water: it still has to be lifted to dry the underside, otherwise mould can form.

Good to know: according to the Government of Canada, a home and its furnishings dried within 48 hours are less likely to grow mould.

And putting it back afterwards? In about 75% of cases, the locking system breaks during removal, whether vinyl or laminate.

“If you don't have water problems at home, laminate is by far the ideal product. In my own home, even today, I would choose laminate.”

Filippo Tomasino
President and CEO of Planchers Payless

And laminates with an HDF core now resist water for 72 to 96 hours.

How can you spot a quality floor in the store?

For vinyl, look at the thickness, ideally 8 to 10 mm; for laminate, look at the resistance class of its surface, from AC3 to AC5.

For vinyl: thickness

The thicker the vinyl, the more material it contains, and the more it costs. Regular vinyl is 5 to 7 mm; the first low-cost models went down to 3 or 4 mm. Most are SPC vinyl, a very rigid composite of plastic and stone powder.

For laminate: the AC rating

Price depends mainly on the finish. The AC rating (AC3, AC4 or AC5) indicates the resistance of the aluminum oxide layer. For near-commercial use, aim for AC5.

Keep in mind: the total thickness shown on the box says nothing about scratch resistance. It tells you about comfort: a thin floor sounds hollow, while 8 or 9 mm vinyl or 12 mm laminate echoes less and creaks less.

Why do so many vinyl floors break?

A thin vinyl floor almost always breaks because the subfloor isn’t perfectly level: as soon as one lock gives way, the whole floor opens up within one to three months.

Laminate causes very few problems: 99% of purchases go well. Vinyl, on the other hand, accounts for 90% to 95% of floating floor problems. Very rigid, it doesn’t forgive any unevenness, and basements are never 100% level. When Planchers Payless sends an inspector, the cause is almost always the same.

Three ways to avoid the problem

  • Pour a self-leveller, a liquid cement-based product that makes the subfloor perfectly even. Effective, but the bill is fairly high.
  • Choose 8 to 10 mm vinyl, whose locking system holds even on an imperfect floor. Expect $4 to $5 per square foot, compared with $2.50 to $3 for 5 to 7 mm vinyl.
  • Opt for glue-down vinyl flooring on concrete or plywood. It won’t lift with water, but the flooring adhesive adds about $1 per square foot.

Laminate vs vinyl flooring: how do they compare?

Prices as of October 2026.

CriteriaVinylLaminate
Common thickness5 to 7 mm, up to 10 mm10 to 12 mm
Product price$2 to $3/sq. ft., $4 to $5 at 8 to 10 mm$2 to $3/sq. ft.
Water resistanceUnlimited time (except floods)72 to 96 hours (HDF core)
ScratchesLow: a key cuts into the surfaceHigh: AC3 to AC5 ratings
Subfloor100% level, otherwise self-levellerTolerates minor unevenness
Recommended roomsBasement, laundry room, entryway, kitchenDry rooms, homes with pets

Ready to choose a floor that will stand the test of time?

Before you buy vinyl or laminate flooring, wherever you shop, ask these four questions:

  • Where will the floor be installed?
  • Will it be mopped with lots of water, or has the house already been flooded?
  • Is the subfloor 100% level?
  • Will a pet be walking on it?

Still hesitating? The Planchers Payless team will advise you based on your room, your subfloor and your budget.

The video summary:

Here’s a short video that recaps the differences between vinyl and laminate, filmed in store at Planchers Payless.

FAQ: vinyl or laminate flooring, how to choose?

Is today's vinyl the same as old-style sheet vinyl?

No. Old-style sheet vinyl was sold in sheets, and today it’s mostly found in high-end commercial versions, in airports for example. Today’s residential vinyl has a different composition and installation, but its look remains less realistic than that of laminate.

Can laminate flooring be installed in a kitchen?

Laminate flooring can go in a kitchen, but it’s not the ideal place. Even though it resists water for 72 to 96 hours, it doesn’t handle the frequent washing of a kitchen well, and the risk of long-term problems remains higher. Planchers Payless recommends vinyl instead.

Are floating floors and laminate floors the same thing?

Not quite. In Quebec, laminate is often called a floating floor. But most vinyl sold is also a floating floor: its planks lock together with a click system, just like laminate. Only glue-down vinyl, attached to concrete or plywood, is the exception.